Reviews: From Victory to Vichy

Click the links below to read reviews of my book, From Victory to Vichy: Veterans in Inter-war France (Manchester: MUP, 2012) – available at Amazon

“From Victory to Vichy is essential reading for anyone interested in interwar political culture, European veterans’ movements, and the persistence of war cultures.  The book is clearly written and organized, which makes it accessible to advanced undergraduate and graduate students.  It is also impressively researched; Millington has mined the archives holding papers on the UNC, UF, and Croix de Feu, in addition to using a wide variety of newspapers and other published sources.  This research has produced an important and original contribution to a crucial period in the history of the Third Republic and twentieth century France.” Caroline Campbell, University of North Dakota, Contemporary French Civilisation, 38 (2)

‘The main strength of the book is its ability to explain something obscure in Inter-War French history, by setting a context, and then explaining its significance.  This is a pattern repeated in each chapter—an overview of the subject is given, then a setting of the broader context before showing how the veterans movement fits into this. The effect of this is to widen the appeal of this book beyond those interested solely by veterans in Inter-War France, and will make this book useful to students of 1930s France…’ Mason Norton, Edge Hill University, Modern and Contemporary France

‘French First World War veterans’ associations have been at the centre of a long and bitter controversy between historians. While French academics, such as Antoine Prost, argued that these associations, despite their inherent antiparliamentarianism, were integrated in an inter-war democratic political culture, the ‘immunity thesis’, France’s allergy to fascism, has been attacked vehemently by scholars such as William Irvine, Robert Soucy or Kevin Passmore… [Millington] excels in bringing new elements to an old debate in order to deconstruct a binary vision.’ Bernard Wilkin, University of Sheffield, French History

‘[Millington] effectively disproves the idea that veterans’ associations were obstacles to the development of fascism or unflagging supporters of democratic values. Along the same lines, Millington does not argue that these veterans brought Vichy into existence, but he contends that they prepared the ground for such a regime… [He] does well to identify larger trends amid a cacophony of veterans’ voices and near continuous political change… [From Victory to Vichy is] a well-written work and an important contribution to the history of veterans and politics in interwar France.’ Gregory M. Thomas
American Historical Review, 11.5, Dec. 2013

‘… an important study, and, in its particular focus on the more right-wing UNC, a useful counterpart to Antoine Prost’s influential work. Despite its avowed refusal to categorize these movements or ascribe them definitive identities, the book does, in fact, offer a valuable analysis of veteran mentalities, and its publication in a ‘cultures of war’ series is thus particularly apt. Indeed, the book will also be of special interest to those researching cultural demobilization — which, as Millington amply demonstrates, could be a dangerously uneven process.  Jessica Wardhaugh H-Sozu-Kult,  http://hsozkult.geschichte.hu-berlin.de/rezensionen/2014-2-076

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s